Hiring a web designer vs. DIY with Wix or Squarespace

What DIY builders do well, where they start costing you leads, and how to tell which one fits where your business is right now.

Paper UI sketches and a sketchbook spread across a wooden desk

If you’ve ever opened Wix or Squarespace, picked a template, and thought “how hard can this be?”, you’re not wrong. These platforms are good. I’ve also seen plenty of business owners spend months of nights and weekends on a DIY site, only to end up with something that looks fine but doesn’t bring in leads.

So let’s skip the sales pitch. Here’s an honest look at both paths, and how to tell which one fits where you are right now.

What DIY builders do well

  • Low upfront cost. A monthly plan is far easier on the budget than a custom project.
  • Fast to launch. If you need something live this week, a template gets you there.
  • Easy updates. Drag-and-drop editors make small changes simple.
  • Hosting is handled. Security, updates and uptime come with the plan.

Where DIY starts to cost you

The price tag is only part of the cost. The rest shows up in places that are harder to see:

  • Your time. Every hour spent nudging a layout is an hour not spent running your business.
  • Looking like everyone else. Popular templates are popular. Your competitors may be using the same one.
  • SEO gaps. The tools are there, but knowing what to set up, and why, is a skill of its own.
  • Hitting the ceiling. Booking, automations, client portals and custom forms can get clunky or impossible.
  • You’re the support team. When something breaks, it’s you and a help center article.

A website isn't just something you have. It's a tool that should bring in leads and take work off your plate.

Side by side

DIY builderHiring a designer
Upfront costLow, monthly planHigher, one-time project
Your timeA lotMostly content and feedback
DesignTemplate-basedBuilt around your brand
SEO setupUp to youBuilt in from the start
Custom featuresLimited to the platformBooking, automations, integrations
SupportHelp centerA real person who knows your site

When DIY is the right call

  • You’re just starting out or testing a new idea.
  • You need a simple, one-page presence for now.
  • Your budget is tight and your time is more flexible than your cash.
  • You genuinely enjoy building it yourself.

There’s no shame in starting with DIY. Plenty of my clients did. A good DIY site now can be the foundation for a stronger one later.

When it’s time to hire

  • Your website needs to bring in leads, not just exist.
  • You’ve outgrown your template, or it no longer matches your brand.
  • You want booking, forms and follow-ups to run on their own.
  • You’d rather spend your hours on the work only you can do.

Questions to ask yourself

  • What do I need my website to do in the next year?
  • How many hours could I realistically put into building and maintaining it?
  • Is my current site helping me win work, or am I working around it?
  • What would it be worth to get those hours back?

If your answers lean toward “it needs to do more,” that’s usually the sign. Still not sure? Book a free call with me. I’ll give you an honest take, even if that means telling you DIY is fine for now.

Michelle Prather
Written byMichelle Prather

I've spent 12 years designing and building websites for businesses of every kind, from the neighborhood bar to Amazon Studios. I write these guides so you can make website decisions with confidence.

More guides on the way

Coming soon

Behind the process

How I use AI in my web design process

Coming soon

AI & automation

Practical ways to use AI to run your business

Not sure which path fits?

Book a free call and we’ll look at your site together. You’ll leave with a clear next step.